Blog
“ Tube Talk ”
'Doctor Who' and the big finale question: Who is John Hurt playing?
Monday, May 20 2013, 10:42pm AEST
By Morgan Jeffery, TV Reporter
"What I did, I did without choice - in the name of peace and sanity."
"But not in the name of the Doctor!"

Umm... what? So Doctor Who's finale on Saturday night climaxed with a stunning final sequence so top-secret that even The Great British Press (we're a bit like The Great Intelligence, only marginally less evil) weren't allowed to see it pre-broadcast.
Deep inside the Doctor's own timestream, viewers apparently met a version of the Time Lord we'd never before encountered in the show's 50-year run. But, despite what the on-screen billing would have you believe, is acting legend John Hurt *really* playing the Doctor? Or is the truth behind his character's identity more complex than that?
Join the Week in Geek for a journey of discovery - and rampant speculation - as we attempt to answer the question... Doctor Who The Hell Was That?!
> Week in Geek - Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D., Dracula: Our take on US TV's new cult shows
> Week in Geek - Hannibal: Bryan Fuller talks the horror drama's cult castings
John Hurt is.... THE REAL NINTH DOCTOR

The Case For - This seems to be the most popular fan theory floating about - that Hurt's Doctor is a previously unseen incarnation originating from the mysterious gap between Paul McGann's brief tenure and Christopher Eccleston's arrival in 2005's 'Rose'.
It'd mean a pretty big rewriting of Who history - knocking each Doctor up a spot so that the Matt Smith model is actually the *12th* take on the Time Lord - but this is the 50th anniversary year, so perhaps all bets are off?
Such a big reveal would certainly tie in with Steven Moffat's claims that the 50th special is "chapter one of a new story" for the show - and it's hard to ignore the fact that, in pictures that have circulated from the set of said special, Hurt appears to be wearing a leather jacket very similar to the one sported by Eccleston and a waistcoat very similar to the one worn by McGann, which would appear to lend credence to the 'in-between' idea.
The Case Against - But why would the Doctor bury his 'real' 9th incarnation deep in his subconscious? Many have speculated that it's because of the terrible crimes he committed during the Time War - but haven't we already seen our hero come to terms with those?
It's possible that there's still some terrible, unseen act which we're yet to be made aware of, but really... what could be worse than blowing up your home planet and (apparently) committing double genocide, wiping out your own race in the process?
"But not in the name of the Doctor!"

© BBC
Matt Smith, Jenna-Louise Coleman in 'Doctor Who'
Umm... what? So Doctor Who's finale on Saturday night climaxed with a stunning final sequence so top-secret that even The Great British Press (we're a bit like The Great Intelligence, only marginally less evil) weren't allowed to see it pre-broadcast.
Deep inside the Doctor's own timestream, viewers apparently met a version of the Time Lord we'd never before encountered in the show's 50-year run. But, despite what the on-screen billing would have you believe, is acting legend John Hurt *really* playing the Doctor? Or is the truth behind his character's identity more complex than that?
Join the Week in Geek for a journey of discovery - and rampant speculation - as we attempt to answer the question... Doctor Who The Hell Was That?!
> Week in Geek - Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D., Dracula: Our take on US TV's new cult shows
> Week in Geek - Hannibal: Bryan Fuller talks the horror drama's cult castings
John Hurt is.... THE REAL NINTH DOCTOR

© BBC
The Case For - This seems to be the most popular fan theory floating about - that Hurt's Doctor is a previously unseen incarnation originating from the mysterious gap between Paul McGann's brief tenure and Christopher Eccleston's arrival in 2005's 'Rose'.
It'd mean a pretty big rewriting of Who history - knocking each Doctor up a spot so that the Matt Smith model is actually the *12th* take on the Time Lord - but this is the 50th anniversary year, so perhaps all bets are off?
Such a big reveal would certainly tie in with Steven Moffat's claims that the 50th special is "chapter one of a new story" for the show - and it's hard to ignore the fact that, in pictures that have circulated from the set of said special, Hurt appears to be wearing a leather jacket very similar to the one sported by Eccleston and a waistcoat very similar to the one worn by McGann, which would appear to lend credence to the 'in-between' idea.
The Case Against - But why would the Doctor bury his 'real' 9th incarnation deep in his subconscious? Many have speculated that it's because of the terrible crimes he committed during the Time War - but haven't we already seen our hero come to terms with those?
It's possible that there's still some terrible, unseen act which we're yet to be made aware of, but really... what could be worse than blowing up your home planet and (apparently) committing double genocide, wiping out your own race in the process?
'The Office' US 2005-2013: A retrospective of Dunder Mifflin's finest
> Click to view this Tube Talk UK entry
Monday, May 20 2013, 2:30am AEST
By Tom Eames, Entertainment Reporter
This Week's Must-See TV: 5 Shows You Shouldn't Miss
> Click to view this Tube Talk UK entry
Sunday, May 19 2013, 6:00pm AEST
By Daniel Sperling, Entertainment Reporter
Christian Slater, Summer Glau: US TV's Biggest Show Killers
Friday, May 17 2013, 9:38pm AEST
By Morgan Jeffery, TV Reporter
If you're a jobbing actor working in US television and you're lucky, you might get a pilot picked up to series. If you're very lucky, that series might go on to become a long-running success. If you're very, very lucky, you might even land two hits shows in your time - nicely done, Bryan Cranston and Michael C Hall.
But some actors seem doomed to briefly taste success, only to have it snatched away from them time and time again. Here's an affectionate tribute to those US TV stars who just can't catch a break - bring on the show killers...
> Friday Fiver - 24 to return: Five things we want to see
> Friday Fiver - Star Trek Into Darkness: The cast's greatest TV hits
Summer Glau
Miss Glau is a cult favourite, with a dedicated fanbase that some actors would kill for. So why do all of her shows get canned?
At two seasons, Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles was her most substantial hit, but The Cape, Dollhouse - on which she played a recurring role - and, of course, Firefly all bit the bullet. Why won't US telly bosses let Summer shine?
But some actors seem doomed to briefly taste success, only to have it snatched away from them time and time again. Here's an affectionate tribute to those US TV stars who just can't catch a break - bring on the show killers...
> Friday Fiver - 24 to return: Five things we want to see
> Friday Fiver - Star Trek Into Darkness: The cast's greatest TV hits
Summer Glau
Miss Glau is a cult favourite, with a dedicated fanbase that some actors would kill for. So why do all of her shows get canned?
At two seasons, Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles was her most substantial hit, but The Cape, Dollhouse - on which she played a recurring role - and, of course, Firefly all bit the bullet. Why won't US telly bosses let Summer shine?
'NCIS: Red', 'Delirium': The US TV pilots that didn't make the cut
Thursday, May 16 2013, 11:15pm AEST
By Morgan Jeffery, TV Reporter
For some, the US TV upfronts is a time of celebration as they receive word that the pilots they've slaved over for months have been picked up to series...
But for others, it's bad news and back to square one - here's a look at the shows that won't be making their way to a television set near you any time soon - did any of this lot deserve a spot on the schedule?
ABC

Two of the most high profile pilots rejected by ABC this season are Doubt - we couldn't buy Steve Coogan as a private eye and apparently neither could the network brass - and supernatural drama Gothica - despite a strong cast, execs were reportedly unsatisfied with how the finished product looked.
A remake of Sky1 comedy Spy is also dead in the water, while after striking out with his Only Fools and Horses remake last year, poor John Leguizamo heads back to development for a second time, as his autobiographical sitcom gets a thumbs down.
McG's Romeo & Juliet update Westside, the pun-tastically titled Keep Calm and Karey On, and single camera sitcom Middle Age Rage won't be progressing to series either.

The bloodbath continues with Disney's Big Thunder - once thought to be a strong contender for a pick-up - plus mother-and-daughter detective drama Murder in Manhattan and comedy Divorce: A Love Story starring perennial show killer Andrea Anders of The Class, Joey and Mr Sunshine infamy.
Reckless - not to be confused with the more successful CBS series of the same name - has also been dropped, but Sharon Horgan's Bad Management is *not* dead and could still be redeveloped.
No such luck for the remake of Horgan's BBC comedy Pulling though - it was thought too edgy for ABC and hasn't won a place on the schedule.
But for others, it's bad news and back to square one - here's a look at the shows that won't be making their way to a television set near you any time soon - did any of this lot deserve a spot on the schedule?
ABC

© PA Images / Ian West/PA Wire
Two of the most high profile pilots rejected by ABC this season are Doubt - we couldn't buy Steve Coogan as a private eye and apparently neither could the network brass - and supernatural drama Gothica - despite a strong cast, execs were reportedly unsatisfied with how the finished product looked.
A remake of Sky1 comedy Spy is also dead in the water, while after striking out with his Only Fools and Horses remake last year, poor John Leguizamo heads back to development for a second time, as his autobiographical sitcom gets a thumbs down.
McG's Romeo & Juliet update Westside, the pun-tastically titled Keep Calm and Karey On, and single camera sitcom Middle Age Rage won't be progressing to series either.

© WENN / Joseph Marzullo
Kristen Schaal's 'Pulling' was thought too edgy for ABC
The bloodbath continues with Disney's Big Thunder - once thought to be a strong contender for a pick-up - plus mother-and-daughter detective drama Murder in Manhattan and comedy Divorce: A Love Story starring perennial show killer Andrea Anders of The Class, Joey and Mr Sunshine infamy.
Reckless - not to be confused with the more successful CBS series of the same name - has also been dropped, but Sharon Horgan's Bad Management is *not* dead and could still be redeveloped.
No such luck for the remake of Horgan's BBC comedy Pulling though - it was thought too edgy for ABC and hasn't won a place on the schedule.
'Cuckoo', 'Law & Order: UK', 'Endeavour': Tube Talk Q&A
> Click to view this Tube Talk UK entry
Thursday, May 16 2013, 10:00pm AEST
By Morgan Jeffery, TV Reporter and Daniel Sperling, Entertainment Reporter
'Agents of S.H.I.E.LD.', 'Dracula': Our take on US TV's new cult shows
Tuesday, May 14 2013, 11:20pm AEST
By Morgan Jeffery, TV Reporter
It's an exciting time of year for tellyheads, with the major US networks all announcing their 2013-14 TV schedules this week. So far, we've got a peek at what Fox and NBC have got planned for the rest of this year and beyond, with ABC, CBS and The CW to follow in the coming days.
> Sleepy Hollow, JJ Abrams drama lead Fox 2013-2014 schedule
> NBC unveils 2013-14 season, confirms new shows
With the first few trailers and clips from upcoming series starting to emerge, this week's Week in Geek is taking a look at those shows that fall under the 'Cult' banner and making a call - is it a potential hit or a flop-in-waiting?
> Week in Geek - Hannibal: Bryan Fuller talks the horror drama's cult castings
> Week in Geek - He-Man, Thundercats and more: Greatest cartoons of the '80s, '90s
Marvel's Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.
The briefest of the new trails at just 30 seconds, ABC's S.H.I.E.L.D. promo still manages to pack in glimpses of Avengers favourites, plenty of explosive action and a dollop of typically Whedon-esque dialogue.
What's more, while I'm aware that a pilot generally has a larger budget than a standard episode of a series, it's exciting to see Agents of S.H.I.E.LD. appearing to match its big-screen Marvel counterparts in terms of production value.
The Week in Geek verdict - Excitement bordering on the unhealthy.
Almost Human
Airing - Mondays at 8/7c
In a very literal sense, Almost Human *looks* amazing - again, you'd probably have to adjust your expectations on a week-by-week basis, but the pilot's realisation of a high-tech future Earth is visually impressive.
Karl Urban and Michael Ealy also look strong as our two leads, but even in this 3-and-half-minute promo, there's some clunky dialogue and cringeworthy moments. Here's hoping that Almost Human isn't all style and no substance.
The Week in Geek verdict - Cautiously optimistic.
Sleepy Hollow
Airing - Mondays at 9/8c
I wasn't convinced by Sleepy Hollow's initial log-line, but this first trailer has gone some way towards changing my opinion.
Alright, so we've seen the 'priggish but good-hearted male hero teamed with sassy female partner' thing done a million times before, but the cast is solid and there's some genuinely creepy moments in this promo.
The Week in Geek verdict - Impressed, but not 100% convinced.
Dracula
Airing - Fridays at 10/9c
Bit of a mixed bag this - Jonathan Rhys Meyers is great casting in the title role and Nonso Anozie (Game of Thrones) makes for a unique but intriguing Renfield, while I'm excited to see what Merlin's Katie McGrath - who barely features in this first promo - will get up to as Lucy Westenra.
But Dracula looks more than a little melodramatic - it could be silly, escapist fun or an unbearable cheese-fest, depending on the execution. The fact that Carnivale's Daniel Knauf is attached is promising, though.
The Week in Geek verdict - Reserving final judgement.
What are your thoughts on US TV's new cult shows? Do they look like hits or disasters? Let us know below!
> Sleepy Hollow, JJ Abrams drama lead Fox 2013-2014 schedule
> NBC unveils 2013-14 season, confirms new shows
With the first few trailers and clips from upcoming series starting to emerge, this week's Week in Geek is taking a look at those shows that fall under the 'Cult' banner and making a call - is it a potential hit or a flop-in-waiting?
> Week in Geek - Hannibal: Bryan Fuller talks the horror drama's cult castings
> Week in Geek - He-Man, Thundercats and more: Greatest cartoons of the '80s, '90s
Marvel's Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.
The briefest of the new trails at just 30 seconds, ABC's S.H.I.E.L.D. promo still manages to pack in glimpses of Avengers favourites, plenty of explosive action and a dollop of typically Whedon-esque dialogue.
What's more, while I'm aware that a pilot generally has a larger budget than a standard episode of a series, it's exciting to see Agents of S.H.I.E.LD. appearing to match its big-screen Marvel counterparts in terms of production value.
The Week in Geek verdict - Excitement bordering on the unhealthy.
Almost Human
Airing - Mondays at 8/7c
In a very literal sense, Almost Human *looks* amazing - again, you'd probably have to adjust your expectations on a week-by-week basis, but the pilot's realisation of a high-tech future Earth is visually impressive.
Karl Urban and Michael Ealy also look strong as our two leads, but even in this 3-and-half-minute promo, there's some clunky dialogue and cringeworthy moments. Here's hoping that Almost Human isn't all style and no substance.
The Week in Geek verdict - Cautiously optimistic.
Sleepy Hollow
Airing - Mondays at 9/8c
I wasn't convinced by Sleepy Hollow's initial log-line, but this first trailer has gone some way towards changing my opinion.
Alright, so we've seen the 'priggish but good-hearted male hero teamed with sassy female partner' thing done a million times before, but the cast is solid and there's some genuinely creepy moments in this promo.
The Week in Geek verdict - Impressed, but not 100% convinced.
Dracula
Airing - Fridays at 10/9c
Bit of a mixed bag this - Jonathan Rhys Meyers is great casting in the title role and Nonso Anozie (Game of Thrones) makes for a unique but intriguing Renfield, while I'm excited to see what Merlin's Katie McGrath - who barely features in this first promo - will get up to as Lucy Westenra.
But Dracula looks more than a little melodramatic - it could be silly, escapist fun or an unbearable cheese-fest, depending on the execution. The fact that Carnivale's Daniel Knauf is attached is promising, though.
The Week in Geek verdict - Reserving final judgement.
What are your thoughts on US TV's new cult shows? Do they look like hits or disasters? Let us know below!
This Week's Must-See TV: 5 Shows You Shouldn't Miss
> Click to view this Tube Talk UK entry
Sunday, May 12 2013, 6:00pm AEST
By Daniel Sperling, Entertainment Reporter
'24' to return: Five things we want to see
Friday, May 10 2013, 7:40pm AEST
By Morgan Jeffery, TV Reporter
Amidst the expected batch of cancellations, renewals and series pick-ups, last night's barrage of US television news also included one *big* surprise - following the cancellation of his series Touch, Kiefer Sutherland is reportedly in talks to reprise his iconic role of Jack Bauer in a new 'limited series' of 24...
But will it actually happen? It's possible that - as with the 24 movie - we'll be treated to another endless string of interviews in which Kiefer tells us that the revived series has "a terrific script" with "a fantastic director in mind" and that now "it's just about scheduling".
On the off-chance that the Jack Bauer Power Hour does return to the small screen, here's our tips for Sutherland, exec producer Howard Gordon and the team - five things we do and don't want to see in the new episodes...

Friday Fiver - Star Trek Into Darkness: The cast's greatest TV hits
Friday FIver - Two Pints, 'Orrible and more: The UK's 5 Worst Sitcoms
Chloe O'Brian
I mean, obviously - it almost doesn't need to be said. She may not have been with the show until it's third season, but at this point, 24 without Chloe (Mary Lynn Rajskub) seems almost unthinkable.
Bring back her husband Morris (Carlo Rota) too - a character whose potential was squandered by a miserable Day Six storyline that robbed him of the charm and humour he'd displayed the previous season.
Tony Almeida
Poor Carlos Bernard - his CTU agent Tony Almeida never really got a fair shake of the stick. Despite being one of the show's longest-running and best-loved characters, his first exit from the series was so badly botched that the 24 writing team chose to bring Tony back from the dead...
But agent Almeida fared little better upon his return - implausibly transformed into a bloodthirsty villain, Tony ended up behind bars at the end of Day Seven. Let's bring him back for a redemption arc, eh?
Aaron Pierce
Along with Jack, Chloe and Tony, one character who *has* to return if 24 does is Aaron Pierce - Glenn Morshower's staunchly loyal government agent appeared with varying degrees of screen-time in each of the show's first seven seasons and it was a travesty - a TRAVESTY - that he was left out of the action for the final run.
"We desperately tried to find a place to put him in and just could not find a place," Howard Gordon told us back in 2010 - with 24 apparently returning to the telly box, now's the chance to correct that mistake!
No nukes
I think it's fair to say that we've all heard Jack yell, "Where is the bomb?!" plenty of times now. A terrorist running around with a nuclear bomb (or "nuclear materials") was one of 24's plot fallbacks - forming a large part of the second, sixth and eighth seasons - and, frankly, it became a little tiresome.
The most thrilling 24 plots centred on a different kind of threat - the virus in season three, the nerve gas in season five - so let's hope that if the show does return, Jack and CTU have to combat a more inventive menace.
No moles in CTU
Jamey Farrell, Nina Myers, Marianne Taylor, Spenser Wolff, Dana Walsh - haven't we had enough moles within CTU by now? And that's even without counting season seven's FBI mole Sean Hillinger (Rhys Coiro) or the countless 'suspected moles' like Day Three's Gael or Day Six's Nadia (Marisol Nichols).
Along with the nukes, the mole sub-plot is one of 24's fallbacks and the show could do with jettisoning this particular 'twist' when/if it returns...
Addendum: Oh, and no cougars or random bouts of amnesia either, thanks.
What do you want to see in the new 24 season? Share your hopes for the new season below!
But will it actually happen? It's possible that - as with the 24 movie - we'll be treated to another endless string of interviews in which Kiefer tells us that the revived series has "a terrific script" with "a fantastic director in mind" and that now "it's just about scheduling".
On the off-chance that the Jack Bauer Power Hour does return to the small screen, here's our tips for Sutherland, exec producer Howard Gordon and the team - five things we do and don't want to see in the new episodes...

© Rex Features / 20th C. Fox/Everett
Kiefer Sutherland in season 4 of '24'
Friday Fiver - Star Trek Into Darkness: The cast's greatest TV hits
Friday FIver - Two Pints, 'Orrible and more: The UK's 5 Worst Sitcoms
Chloe O'Brian
I mean, obviously - it almost doesn't need to be said. She may not have been with the show until it's third season, but at this point, 24 without Chloe (Mary Lynn Rajskub) seems almost unthinkable.
Bring back her husband Morris (Carlo Rota) too - a character whose potential was squandered by a miserable Day Six storyline that robbed him of the charm and humour he'd displayed the previous season.
Tony Almeida
Poor Carlos Bernard - his CTU agent Tony Almeida never really got a fair shake of the stick. Despite being one of the show's longest-running and best-loved characters, his first exit from the series was so badly botched that the 24 writing team chose to bring Tony back from the dead...
But agent Almeida fared little better upon his return - implausibly transformed into a bloodthirsty villain, Tony ended up behind bars at the end of Day Seven. Let's bring him back for a redemption arc, eh?
Aaron Pierce
Along with Jack, Chloe and Tony, one character who *has* to return if 24 does is Aaron Pierce - Glenn Morshower's staunchly loyal government agent appeared with varying degrees of screen-time in each of the show's first seven seasons and it was a travesty - a TRAVESTY - that he was left out of the action for the final run.
"We desperately tried to find a place to put him in and just could not find a place," Howard Gordon told us back in 2010 - with 24 apparently returning to the telly box, now's the chance to correct that mistake!
No nukes
I think it's fair to say that we've all heard Jack yell, "Where is the bomb?!" plenty of times now. A terrorist running around with a nuclear bomb (or "nuclear materials") was one of 24's plot fallbacks - forming a large part of the second, sixth and eighth seasons - and, frankly, it became a little tiresome.
The most thrilling 24 plots centred on a different kind of threat - the virus in season three, the nerve gas in season five - so let's hope that if the show does return, Jack and CTU have to combat a more inventive menace.
No moles in CTU
Jamey Farrell, Nina Myers, Marianne Taylor, Spenser Wolff, Dana Walsh - haven't we had enough moles within CTU by now? And that's even without counting season seven's FBI mole Sean Hillinger (Rhys Coiro) or the countless 'suspected moles' like Day Three's Gael or Day Six's Nadia (Marisol Nichols).
Along with the nukes, the mole sub-plot is one of 24's fallbacks and the show could do with jettisoning this particular 'twist' when/if it returns...
Addendum: Oh, and no cougars or random bouts of amnesia either, thanks.
What do you want to see in the new 24 season? Share your hopes for the new season below!


























